How To Handle A Short Story Demanding To Be Turned Into Something Bigger #Writing #AmWriting

#flashfiction #shortstory #amwriting

Short story / writer relationships are very different to novel / writer relationships.

With a short story there is no creative fatigue. You don’t have night terrors about editing and it’s all wrapped up in a couple of pages, as opposed to dragging on for thirty chapters. Your creative life feels blissful, fun and carefree.

You write a short story, edit it, revise it and share it. After doing all this you put it aside, as in your head it is time to move onto something else. Your short story, however, has other ideas…


It refuses to leave you alone, climbing into your head whilst you sleep and entering your dreams.

As you rise in the morning you feel its presence inside your mind. You go about your daily life trying to ignore it and telling yourself ‘it was just a short story!’  But it won’t go away…

A week later and it is still stalking you in the small hours, hanging out with you whilst you clean the loo and sat in the passenger seat as you drive to work.

It starts to whisper ‘write more of me,’ and ‘I should be a novel!’  which makes you wonder whether this is the start of insanity.

Here’s my advice on handling this challenging situation.

  1. Expect to enter a denial phase. In your head you will run through all the reasons why you can’t write more of this short story; it was only meant to be a bit of fun, you were not looking for anything serious and it wouldn’t work as a novel.
  2. Prepare for the short story stalking phase to last a long time. Some stories refuse to leave you alone and I hate to say this, but I have heard story stalking to go on for weeks and even months.
  3. Expect the short stories to play dirty. Short stories can be demanding and troublesome literary beings. They are also very determined and will bug the hell out of you for as long as it takes to get you to pay them some attention. Expect all sorts of weird stuff happening to you. Your short story is trying to get your attention.
  4. Tell it to be patient. Best of luck with this one.
  5. Life’s too short so give it what it wants! Go on, be a devil, write it, turn it into something bigger.

I hope none of you are busy ignoring the demands of a great short story!

What has been your experience with short stories?

Have a fabulous day!

Photo: Upsplash

Posted by

Lucy Mitchell lives in South Wales with her husband, her two teenage daughters, a giant labrador and a gang of unruly cats. Lucy is the author of the award winning blog, BlondeWriteMore and was a Featured Romance Author on Wattpad. When she’s not working or writing, Lucy can be found listening to audiobooks in a muddy field with her dog or sat outside her local pub in the sunshine enjoying a glass of wine. Her debut novel Instructions Falling In Love Again is OUT now and already pulling in some fabulous reviews ❤️

87 thoughts on “How To Handle A Short Story Demanding To Be Turned Into Something Bigger #Writing #AmWriting

  1. Ha! Yess so much! It took a year of denial and mediation for me to start writing the novel. My friend kept telling me to “finish the story” and I kept saying “that’s the end! The main character dies at the end, how can there be more story?” Them gosh-darn characters just don’t stay dead though 😉 haha

  2. Ha! That was a fun read! None of my short stories have become novels yet unfortunately… But maybe that’s because the idea for a novel still hasn’t arrived 😎

  3. Lol – brilliant. I’ve had stories stalk me. I punished them by turning them into short stories. They punish me back by turning those shorts into novellas, which then become full-fledged novels. Which, obviously, become series. I’m now waiting to see where this nightmare will end. Hollywood, anyone?

  4. Yes, I am busy ignoring them but there’s no need to yell at me for it. 😉 I write a lot of micro and flash so they often beg to be made into longer stories. As for a novel, I’m not sure that would work. So, interestingly enough, my problem is micro fiction needing to be short stories not short stories into novels. Did I confuse everyone?

  5. I feel like I’m stuck in Phase 1-bliss. There isn’t a story that demands my attention to be written as a novel. I have had ideas to write an anthology of short stories centered around a theme or setting. Recently, I finished a book where the main story was broken into stories where secondary characters had some interaction with the main characters. It was a good book. I’m thinking about trying something like that.

  6. my one YA book, still in the ‘to be edited’ section of My Documents grew from a short story and now wants to be a series… I’m thinking of putting it up for adpotion

  7. I’ve a couple of short stories that have been trying to give me ideas. One story has me thinking of trying to make a series along the same lines as it (sort of a Fantasy version of Nancy Drew), and one story has me thinking of actually turning it into a book (thanks to reader’s suggestion).

  8. Just going through this now. Written what was supposed to be a short story (thought a bit on the long side), and now it seems to be hinting that it wants to be even longer. This is why I have no short stories. :/

  9. Haha! You’re so funny! Sacha is right, this is exactly what has happened to me with Swanskin… it was only ever meant to be a short and simple novella, but beta readers are FORCING me to turn it into a novel. I am kicking and screaming against it but they’re just ignoring me. Sigh. And I really cant stop thinking about it…

      1. You are welcome. I find the idea of a “short story stalking” the writer interesting. That, itself, sounds like an X-Files episode. 😈 👽

  10. I think I’m going backwards. Started working on a novel, then caved to writing short stories – started with stories within the universe of the novel, then went completely unrelated. I’m pretty sure the new babies will haunt me at some point, haha! Anyway, great post 🙂

  11. I loved this post! Sometimes I truly despise the space and old short story occupies in my mind, because it adds another large project I’d like to finish to my Neverending pile of projects.
    I really enjoyed your perspective, thanks for sharing.

  12. Ms. Mitchell, just wanted to say very true, very true. I wrote an 8 page short story once, titled They’re Dead and put it in a folder. Years later I found it, thought about it and the short story became my second novel, The Cards. Ideas never die, though, writers I suppose do! Any how thanks for your great blog post.

  13. So true. I just stumbled upon your post, and it pretty well sums up a few of my shorts, constantly rattling in my noggin, wanting to be expanded (or made into a graphic novel). One of the most wonderful thing about flash and shorts, in my opinion, is that you can let yourself be enthused and inspired by a story and have a first draft in the same day. Sure, you may want to revisit and revise, perhaps expand to full-length, but that first blast of inspiration is so pure and wonderful in its near instant-satisfaction speed.

  14. I am hoping that I will be inspired to challenge myself to something longer one day, so far only written a few short stories, (been writing for about a year) I lie thinking about them being read on radio four, perhaps I need to think about screen plays and actually finding out if anyone likes them.

      1. You blog is still turning over in my mind. The author of a short story has a liberty that a novelist doesn’t. And I think the reader understands that.

      2. Agree. I also think that writers rush to write novels and miss the opportunity to validate the concept via a short story first. I think short stories are so important for writers and sometimes overlooked.

  15. Oh no! I hadn’t even realised this could happen. I’ve always been okay at just letting it be.. I’m not going to be able to sleep tonight now. Darn those short stories!

  16. I wrote a short story recently and after its completion, I decided to make it a part of a series . . . so now, I have a never-ending “short” story, hahaha. I enjoyed this post; much relate-able.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.