5 Things I Have Learned About Writing Second Books #Writer #Writing @bookish_yogi


I have invited author Rachel Burton back to guest post on BlondeWriteMore for several reasons:

  1. Her last guest post, ‘5 Things I Wish I had Known Whilst Writing My First Novel, did well and it resulted in me smiling at my blog stats bar graph.
  2. I have just finished reading her debut novel, ‘The Many Colours of Us’ and it has taken me a few days to get over it. I believe this is a sign of a good book. If you haven’t read it check this out for an opening – young woman discovers she has inherited millions from her famous father, who she’d never met and whilst she is recovering from the shock of this, finds herself dumped by her boyfriend of ten years, who wants to go work in America. This start certainly made me sit up in my reading chair!
  3. I think the subject of writing second books needs to be the focus of more blog posts. After the drama of writing your first book you swear to yourself you will never write another, I mean who in their right mind would put themselves through all that pain again? A few weeks later you find yourself, camped out in Writing Corner, wrapped in a warm blanket, sipping warm tea and telling yourself writing the second book will be so much easier than crafting your first – ha!

So, here is Rachel Burton with her guest post:

Rachel B pic

Five things I’ve learned about second books

It is a truth universally acknowledged that second books are difficult beasts. There is a lot of expectation, particularly if your first has done well, there is usually a deadline and often a lot of people’s opinions to take into account. All in all it’s very different to writing your first – which in general you are often writing completely for yourself.

I spent the best part of three years on my first book. I wrote my second in eleven months. In that time I re-wrote the whole thing twice and went through two big structural edits; one with my agent and one with my editor. It was eye-opening to say the least and here are a few things I learned:-

1. Trust your gut

As I said, there will probably be a lot more people involved in this book. With your first will mostly have been all alone, or at most being buoyed along by friends or a writing group. I wrote my debut The Many Colours of Us by myself in my free time, while working full-time and running a business. I didn’t take it very seriously until it was almost finished. In truth I never really believed it would be finished until it got there.

Book 2 was very different. I had a lot of people around me offering support and advice – my publisher, my editor, my agent. On the plus side this was great because when I got stuck I had people to bounce ideas off, people to suggest different themes that I could explore, people to help me develop characters. On the negative side…I had a lot of people around me offering support and advice!! Ever heard the phrase “too many cooks spoil the broth”?

If you don’t trust your gut with your second novel there’s a chance this might happen. I got to a point where my agent, myself and my editor all had a different set of ideas about where the book should go. In the end I had to back away, spend some time alone with my characters – and this is what led to the first major rewrite.

Your editor and agent want your book to do well, they want to help you produce the best work you possibly can. But at the end of the day you know your characters, you know how they would behave – take all the advice you’ve been given but ultimately trust your characters and yourself.

2. Plan, plan, plan

Confession. I didn’t plan my first book at all. I just sat down and wrote and waited to see what would happen. This is part of the reason it took three years.

Now I know planning doesn’t work for everyone, but I realised that if I had to write a book in a year I needed to know exactly where I was going. I split the book into three acts and I worked out exactly what would happen in each act – beginning, middle and end. This helped me write a specific number of words per week that I would need to reach my goal. I can’t plan chapter by chapter like some people do, but I really found this method helped me have a clearer path to my end goal.

3. Get a betareader

Betareaders are kind people who will read and comment honestly on your work. There will come a point in your drafting and editing when you, your agent and your editor will all be a little bit too close to the book to get perspective. This is where a betareader is invaluable. I was lucky enough to have three wonderful readers who all read different drafts and all helped immeasurably (you guys know who you are!).

I know it’s a scary prospect letting other people read your book but remember, by this point you’ve got a book out in the world and lots of people are reading it. Take a deep breath and give it a go – I have never regretted asking a betareader to help out.

4. Read, read, read

This one is self-explanatory. Keep reading – read in your genre, around your genre, outside of your genre. Read fiction and non-fiction, read the news, read everything. You never know where inspiration might come from. I tend to read in my own genre while I’m sitting on an idea and during the first draft and then when it comes to second drafts and subsequent edits I read outside of my genre (mostly in case I accidentally plagiarise, but also for a break).

5. Keep being you!

You are completely unique, your narrative voice, your characters, the way you choose to tell a story. Write the story you want to tell. Your agent and editor will help you tell that story in the best possible way so that it can (hopefully!) be commercially successful – but ultimately this is all you.

While working with my editor on the last edit of my second book we came across an idea we didn’t agree on. Eventually (after a sleepless night) I broached the subject of not being happy with this edit. When I explained why to my editor she was on my side and helped me work the book in a different way.

So before you start work on an edit you are not 100% comfortable with remember: it’s your name on the cover.

Thank you Rachel for another excellent post! 

If you are looking for a good book about someone who unearths a lot of family secrets and finds herself falling in love with a handsome lawyer, check out Rachel’s book.


The link to the Amazon.com version can be found here.

If you are about to start writing your second, I wish you well, my friend!

Have a great day.

Posted by

Lucy Mitchell lives in South Wales with her husband, her two teenage daughters, a giant labrador and a gang of unruly cats. Lucy is the author of the award winning blog, BlondeWriteMore and was a Featured Romance Author on Wattpad. When she’s not working or writing, Lucy can be found listening to audiobooks in a muddy field with her dog or sat outside her local pub in the sunshine enjoying a glass of wine. Her debut novel Instructions Falling In Love Again is OUT now and already pulling in some fabulous reviews ❤️

20 thoughts on “5 Things I Have Learned About Writing Second Books #Writer #Writing @bookish_yogi

  1. Great post 🙂
    I am with her, on the planning. It’s a must.
    Even if you don’t like to plan your first book, on the second things, get a lot more complicated, lol, so I think planning is the best thing to do 😀

  2. This was really interesting and I can really see the difference between writing your second book compared to writing your first. The Many Colours of Us sounds great too- I’m adding it to my “list”.

  3. Some valuable insights here, even for those who are working on their first book. My first is a memoir which I began in 2015 February. I am still writing it. I completely agree with everything she’s said. It’s important to know why you want to write the book. Thank you for hosting her!

  4. Trying really really really really hard not to be jealous about #secondbook challenges when I’m still working through second chapter nightmares…

    But in all seriousness, this is great advice regardless of the stage of writing we’re struggling through. Thanks!

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.